Fault Traces: Civilian Architectural Responses in the Syrian Civil War

  • Image
    Stills from a documentary: a boy mixes cement, collects it, applies it onto a stone and places a jagged piece on top.
    This is a simple example of civilian architectural responses. A boy mixes cement in an oil tin, collects it, applies it onto a stone and places a jagged piece on top to build an improvised shelter where a glass storefront once stood.
    Omar Ferwati
    Al Jazeera. “Death of Aleppo.” Documentary. 2016. bit.ly/2NlJdqn
  • Image
    Elevation drawing diagram of urban interventions for movement and shelter including tarps, barrels, rubble, and sandbags.
    Diagram of urban interventions for movement and shelter. 1. Tarps; used to enclose unfinished or damaged structures 2. Barrels; filled with rubble and lined to create barrier 3. Rubble; assembled in a pile, used to infill, or to reinforce building opening
    Omar Ferwati
    Illustration by Author
  • Image
    Video stills from YouTube video showing the passage through a home to avoid sniper fire on a main street.
    Movement 01; video stills from YouTube video showing the passage through a home to avoid sniper fire on a main street.
    Omar Ferwati
    Shams Alhorya. “حلب : الجلوم :طريقة الإنتقال من حي الجلوم إلى حي الكلاسة .” YouTube video, 1:50. March 13, 2013. bit.ly/2VcmxwU.
  • Image
    Axonometric analytical drawing of the civilian path highlighted in blue and a detail of the intervention, a hole in a wall dividing two homes for people to pass through.
    Movement 02; axonometric analytical drawing of the civilian path and their intervention derived from the video and a detail of the intervention
    Omar Ferwati
    Illustration by Author
  • Image
    Footage from social media and news reports of a damaged hospital with a protective wall around it built by locals to protect it.
    Civil Space 01; footage from social media and news reports of a damaged hospital with a protective wall around it built by locals to protect it.
    Omar Ferwati
    Top Left: Ruptly. “Syria: Drone captures the destruction of Aleppo.” YouTube video, 01:29. December 18, 2016. bit.ly/2Z6mCDF Top right: M2 Hospital, Facebook Bottom right: Sky News. “معركة حلب.. العتاد يصل المعارضة .” YouTube video, 11:41. September 28
  • Image
    An axonometric drawing of a damaged hospital with a protective wall built around it by locals highlighted in blue and a construction detail.
    Civil Space 02; An axonometric drawing of the damaged hospital with a protective wall built around it by locals and a detail of its construction. The protective wall is made of concrete masonry units (CMU) between a regular reinforced concrete frame and w
    Omar Ferwati
    Illustration by Author
  • Image
    Axonometric drawing of Usama bin Zaid mosque and its added tanks by the ICRC highlighted in blue.
    Infrastructure 01; axonometric drawing of Usama bin Zaid mosque and its added tanks by the ICRC.
    Omar Ferwati
    Illustration by Author
  • Image
    A map of Aleppo that shows a compilation of layers of conflict including damage, frontlines, acts of violence, and places of civilian architectural responses of survival.
    The layers of Aleppo in conflict: a compilation of found data in the research including acts of violence during fighting and acts of civilian architectural response for survival. This is still only a partial idea of the complexity of the urban reality of
    Omar Ferwati
    Illustration by Author Civil space fronts data: Physicians for Human Rights Infrastructure counterfronts data: ICRC Residential damage percentage data: UNOSAT
Author
Omar Ferwati

Examining Committee Members

Supervisor
Committee Member
Internal Reader
External Examiner
Eyal Weizman, Professor of Spatial and Visual Cultures at Goldsmiths, University of London

In the discourse of urban warfare, architecture normally has two roles: it is the object of destruction during fighting, and the object of reconstruction after conflict ends. There is little consideration for a third role of architecture: construction that happens in the heat of conflict. During the Battle of Aleppo (2012 – 2016) in Syria, combatants depended on the city to fight and in doing so radically transformed it. Combatants in Aleppo, like in most contemporary conflicts, created, targeted, and manipulated urban space for power. When the city transformed to both battlefield and weapon, its residents were at risk in their own homes and neighbourhoods. Contrary to our perception of civil society during crisis however, people in Aleppo were not just passive victims of war; they were active participants in shaping the city but for survival rather than power. I refer to this urban phenomenon as ‘civilian architectural response,’ where people must cope with violence by creating and changing the urban space around them. Their interventions in the city could be anything from building new structures, to altering existing ones, to creating new resource networks. Civilian architectural responses give necessary insight into the effects of war on civil society at the human scale, embody a new collective memory, and inform resilient visions of reconstruction.

What makes Aleppo and other conflict cities today different from earlier wars is the ability for outsiders to peer into the place of conflict as it happens. Thanks to the contemporary ubiquity of phone cameras and social media, people document almost every act of war and broadcast it to the world. In that footage is an opportunity to fill the gap between our understanding of architecture as a target of destruction, and architecture as a project of reconstruction. 

In this thesis I investigate, document, and analyse civilian architectural responses in Aleppo during the Syrian Civil War. I consider each case from its materiality, to its urban environment, to its place in the conflict. I also outline a method based on forensics and crowd-sourced footage to conduct this analysis. I compose responses into three types: movement, civil space – where residents live – and infrastructure. Each section begins with a look at the violent, urban forces that threatened civil society followed by an account of the civilian architectural responses that resisted them.
 

Project Date
Future History: Theory + Culture
Planet in Crisis: Territories, Cities + Landscape
Completed